Would They Notice?

We’re going to set the stage for this post by saying from the onset that in the scenario we paint, the fictitious breeder is a conscientious, health-testing preservation breeder, and that our fictitious puppy buyer is not a fancier, he or she simply wants a canine companion, and has no interest in showing or breeding the dog.

We also mention that very rarely is every puppy in a litter a show dog, let alone a Best in Show dog.

We’ll add that some breeders charge the same for a show prospect as they do a pet puppy, while others charge more for a show quality youngster. This post is not about the pros and cons of either approach, so please move past that. This post is about aspects of a puppy that disqualify it from being a show quality dog, but are details that are usually unnoticed by a non-fancier.  The issue comes up in our fictitious scenario when a potential buyer wants to know what it is about their puppy that makes it a pet quality dog, and not a show prospect.  Our contention is that most of the time, it’s a detail that anyone unfamiliar with the breed standard even notices.

We use the Black and Tan Coonhound to make the point, and we caution that we are not Black and Tan Coonhound experts. It takes years to know a breed inside and out, and we’re sharing this example after reviewing the breed’s Illustrated Standard for a short time. The creators of that Guide, however, have done such a good job of illustrating a point that we hope to come even a little close to making our point.

Take a look at the three Coonhounds below, and consider their ears, for this is the aspect on which we are honing in. A Black and Tan Coonhound fancier may find other issues, but we’re just looking at ears. The AKC breed standard reads:

Ears are low set and well back. They hang in graceful folds, giving the dog a majestic appearance. In length they extend naturally well beyond the tip of the nose and are set at eye level or lower. Penalize ears that do not reach the tip of the nose and are set too high on the head.


Bearing in mind that we are not Black and Tan Coonhound experts, it still strikes us that the dog at the left (and seen below) has decently set ears, but they would be faulted for lacking “graceful folds” as written in the standard. 


The dog at the far right (and seen below) seems to have ears that are set too high. We wonder, too if the ears would reach the tip of the nose….


The dog in the middle (and seen below) has lovely folds, but ears that are set too low.




Again, we aren’t fanciers of this breed,  but we suspect someone wanting a Black and Tan Coonhound companion would probably not notice ear set, length, or folds. They would likely see a friendly face with melting brown eyes, a shiny black coat with rich tan markings, ears that are velvety soft – and fall in love.  We would.

An exercise like this invites discussion, and we welcome it because this is the stuff of which National Specialties and Dog Shows are made. Our point here, however, is to underscore the details  that go into a show quality dog of any breed. Details that anyone who is not a fancier might not notice.

Top artwork image: “Elvis Lip” by Aloe Artwork is available as fine art, and in home decor and lifestyle items here. All other photos are from copyright free stock photo sites. 

2 thoughts on “Would They Notice?”

  1. — Dog on left- I agree with your comment about the ear set and also the lack of inward folds.
    — Dog on the right, in the thumbnail at the top of the article, there appears to be pressure on the ears from the collar being held up tight. I would want to see the collar dropped a bit to see the natural earset. And in the larger picture below, the dog appears to be raising his ears – hounds will do this if there is a scent that is interesting them, a sight that is interesting to them, or a girl in season. I’d like to see this dog’s ear in a more natural and relaxed state.
    — Dog in the middle is a *puppy*. That gives it the advantage, in Coonhounds as well as in Bassets, of not having yet grown into their ears! So they look super long compared the length of the head, and generally the skin is still very soft and finer than it will be as an adult. I would definitely want to kiss that pup’s nose, and love the look, but what will it be as an adult? I don’t know yet.

    So the pup, today, would to me have the best current ear set. But I’m not sure it’s a apples-to-apples comparison. And if we were at a National Specialty, that would kick off, I’m sure, a VERY fine dinner conversation as everyone weighed in! 🙂

    • Great insights, Sylvie! we’re still looking into “curl to ear!”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *